Things are only getting worse for Carrie Underwood. After igniting controversy with her unexpected remark about co-host Jamal Roberts last month—where she was criticized for what many perceived as a dismissive tone—Underwood has added fuel to the fire with a new comment that’s left fans stunned and critics piling on.
When asked during a backstage interview whether she planned to return next season to host Sunday Night Football, Underwood paused and replied, “There’s a lot to consider.” Though vague, the comment immediately sent shockwaves through both fan circles and entertainment media. For many, it was the final straw.
Social media erupted almost instantly. Comments ranged from confusion to outright outrage, with some longtime fans accusing her of being noncommittal, while others revisited her earlier dust-up with Roberts. “She used to be America’s sweetheart. Now she’s just acting like the spotlight’s too bright,” one fan wrote on X.
Behind the scenes, speculation is growing that NBC may already be exploring alternatives. Sources close to the network say several names have been floated as potential replacements if Underwood steps away—or is asked to. Country star Kelsea Ballerini, pop icon Kelly Clarkson, and even former Voice coach Jennifer Hudson are reportedly on the shortlist.
As for Underwood, she’s yet to issue any further clarification. But the silence isn’t doing her any favors. A once-beloved figure who brought glamour and powerhouse vocals to sports television may now be at risk of losing her most visible gig—and a major part of her fan base.
Who do you think should replace her if she doesn’t return? Drop your thoughts in the comments below.
